naomibi Annotations

What does this community believe about the role of knowledge infrastructures in stabilizing meaning?

Wednesday, February 14, 2024 - 6:15am

Data and knowledge are described as inseperable from one another. In the document it says: "In many cases, data can not be interpreted without knowledge [...]." (p. 10) and that data and knowledge form a "continuous spectrum". Moreover, they have quite open definitions of data and knowledge. In the same paragraph it says: "

"Data can be of any nature, including among others, spatial or non-spatial, qualitative or quantitative, descriptive, and from all scientific disciplines. This includes information from indigenous peoples and local communities (IPLC);
Knowledge is the understanding gained through experience, reasoning, interpretation, perception, intuition, and learning that is developed as a result of information use and processing."
Creative Commons Licence

How does this community understand the relationship between numbers and truth?

Wednesday, February 14, 2024 - 6:07am

Data and data integration is framed as a possibility for a better understanding of nature and its contribution to a good quality of life. At the same time the intent of a data management policy is to make the usage of data transparent. 

One possible interpretation of this is that data is not posited in a positivistic way of representing a truth, but as approximations to the truth. Because they are only approximations, data has to be made transparent and open to contestation. However, it also implies that more data and better practices of data integration will lead to better approximation of the truth.

Creative Commons Licence